<< View All Blogs

Comparable Sales Report: Read It and Lower Your Texas Taxes

Articles
Nov 20, 2026

Key Takeaways:

A comparable sales report lists recent sales of homes like yours, adjusts their prices for differences, and shows what your home would likely sell for. If that number comes in below your appraisal district’s value, you have a case for a lower tax bill. I’m Ryder Meehan, Founder and Licensed Property Tax Consultant at TaxDrop. I’ve owned rentals in Dallas and Grayson counties since 2012, and I’ve read hundreds of these reports. Most owners never open theirs.

This guide shows you how to read one, line by line. It also shows which sales count, which ones to throw out, and how the report turns into a lower value. At TaxDrop, our licensed consultants build this evidence for you, and you pay only if your tax bill goes down.

TL;DR

  • A comparable sales report (a “comp report”) shows sold properties similar to yours, with price adjustments for differences.
  • Texas law sets the rules for what counts as comparable: similar features, and sales within 24 months of the valuation date in most cases.
  • Read three numbers first: net adjustment, indicated value, and median value. Then compare them to your appraised value.
  • Three to five clean comps beat a stack of loose ones.
  • You can ask your appraisal district for the sales it used before your hearing.

Table of Contents

What a comparable sales report actually is

Start with the idea behind it. The Texas Comptroller explains that the sales comparison approach bases value on what similar properties sold for. It then adjusts those prices for differences between each sold property and yours. The Comptroller says this approach is typically preferred for single-family homes and vacant land when enough sales data exists.

The same page tells you the target date. With few exceptions, Tax Code §23.01 requires appraisal districts to value property at market value as of January 1. So every sale gets judged against that date.

A comp report is raw data and math. It isn’t an appraisal. An appraisal is a licensed professional’s opinion that includes a physical look at the property. A comp report is the sales evidence that supports an opinion about value.

You’ll run into two versions:

  • The district’s report. The appraisal district builds it to defend its own number.
  • Your report. You (or your consultant) build it to show a lower number.

Both use the same logic. The difference is which sales get picked. That’s where most protests are won or lost.

How to read the columns

Every appraisal district formats its report a little differently. The terms are close enough that one example teaches you most of it. Bastrop CAD’s report description spells out the common fields.

Field What it tells you
Sale Date When the sale closed. Newer and closer to January 1 is better.
Sale Price What the buyer paid.
Sale Price/SQFT Price divided by living area. Good for a quick sanity check.
% Good Adjustment Adjustment for age and condition.
Main Area Segment Adjustment Adjustment for size and quality.
Net Adjustment The total of all adjustments, up or down.
Indicated Value Sale price plus or minus the net adjustment. This is what the comp says your home is worth.
Mean and Median Value The average and middle of all the indicated values.

The indicated value is the number that matters. Say a comp sold for $380,000. The report adjusts it up $12,000 because the comp is smaller than your home. The indicated value is $392,000.

Do that for each comp. Then look at the middle value. That’s your estimate of market value.

Some districts show a full grid instead. Collin CAD’s residential grid model sets your home beside similar sales, adjusts each sale for differences, and typically includes at least three sales. It then compares the indicated value range to the current appraisal. Same idea, different layout.

Read the adjustments with suspicion

Adjustments are where reports go wrong. A big net adjustment means the comp isn’t very similar to your home. When a comp needs a $60,000 adjustment, I stop trusting it.

I look for three things:

  1. Do the adjustments point the right way? A bigger comp should be adjusted down.
  2. Are they sized reasonably? A pool or extra bedroom shouldn’t swing the price by a random amount.
  3. Is there a market adjustment? Prices move between the sale date and January 1, and the law expects you to account for that.

Which sales count as comparable in Texas

Texas doesn’t leave this to taste. Tax Code §23.013 says comparability rests on similarities in location, lot size, home square footage, age, condition, access, amenities and views. For income property it also looks at income, operating expenses and occupancy.

Two similar homes on a Texas residential street

The same section sets the time window. A sale generally has to fall within 24 months of the valuation date. For residential property in counties with more than 150,000 people, the window is 36 months. The law also requires you to adjust for market changes between the sale date and the valuation date.

The Comptroller’s Property Tax Basics guide (January 2026 edition) repeats the 24-month rule. It adds one exception: a longer window can apply when too few similar sales exist to make a representative sample.

In plain terms, the best comp:

  • sits in your neighborhood, often on your street or the next one
  • has similar square footage, age and build quality
  • sold close to January 1
  • sold at arm’s length, meaning a normal sale between unrelated parties
  • needs small adjustments

What I’d skip

I’d skip a few things that show up in many protest packets.

Neighbors’ appraised values. Owners love to say, “My neighbor’s house is bigger and appraised lower.” That’s a fair point for an unequal appraisal protest, which asks whether you’re valued higher than similar homes. It doesn’t prove market value. The Tarrant Appraisal District’s hearing guide (2023) says appraised values of neighboring properties generally aren’t useful to establish market value. Know which ground you’re protesting before you pick evidence.

Asking prices. A listing shows what a seller hopes for. A closed sale shows what a buyer paid. Use closed sales.

Far-off sales. A home across town, even a great match on paper, invites an easy rebuttal. Stay close.

What I’d do differently from the usual advice

Common advice says to bring as many comps as you can find. I disagree. Ten loose comps give the review board ten places to poke holes. Three to five tight comps, each with small adjustments, make a cleaner case. Quality wins.

A worked example

Here’s a made-up but realistic case. The numbers are for illustration only.

Your district appraises your home at $400,000. You pull four recent sales close to January 1:

Comp Sale price Net adjustment Indicated value
A $372,000 +$8,000 $380,000
B $355,000 +$10,000 $365,000
C $368,000 −$6,000 $362,000
D $361,000 +$4,000 $365,000

The indicated values run from $362,000 to $380,000. The median is $365,000.

You’d ask for a market value of $365,000. That’s $35,000 below the district’s number. At an assumed combined tax rate of 2.2%, the yearly tax saved is about $770 ($35,000 × 0.022).

Tax rates differ by city, county, school district and special district. Your own bill shows your actual rate. Plug it in to estimate your savings.

Notice what makes this report strong. Every adjustment is small. The sales cluster. No comp is a wild outlier. A review board can follow it in two minutes.

Using the report in your protest

A comp report only helps if you file on time and present it correctly. The Comptroller’s protest page says owners who disagree with their value file Form 50-132 with the appraisal review board (ARB) by May 15 or 30 days after the notice is mailed, whichever is later. The ARB is the local panel that hears disputes. Our Texas protest deadline guide covers the timing in more detail.

The same page says you can ask for an informal conference. There you can show evidence such as comparable sales, repair estimates, sales-price documents and photos.

Ask for the district’s sales first

The Comptroller’s model hearing procedures say you can make a written request before the hearing for the evidence the district plans to use. That likely includes the sales it picked and your appraisal card. Do this early. If the district’s comps are weaker than yours, you’ll see it before you walk in.

Those procedures also warn that saying “my value is too high” rarely wins. You need sales, documents or sworn statements. And your evidence must stick to the grounds you listed on your protest form, because the ARB can’t rule on matters you didn’t protest.

Know the hearing rules in Tarrant and Denton

If you own in Tarrant County, the TAD guide gives hard numbers. Hearings run 15 minutes total, with about five minutes per side per ground. Bring four copies of your evidence and two copies of photos, on 8.5x11 single-sided paper. Third-party verified sales closest to January 1 carry the most weight.

Denton County owners follow the same state rules and the same May deadline. Your appraisal district sets its own filing portal and hearing logistics, so check its site. Whichever county you’re in, the report format changes a little but the logic doesn’t.

A 2025 change helps too. According to a TAAD summary of HB 1533, the bill took effect September 1, 2025. It requires appraisal districts in counties of 120,000 or more to update posted appraisal records weekly. It also lets owners elect telephone or video hearings for protests filed after that date. Check your district’s site for how to request one.

Falsified documents are a crime under Chapter 37 of the Texas Penal Code, per the TAD guide. Use real sales and real photos.

Build the packet

A clean packet has:

  1. Your protest form and a one-page summary of the value you’re asking for
  2. Your comp grid with sale dates, prices, adjustments and indicated values
  3. Photos of your property’s condition, plus repair estimates if needed
  4. Proof for each sale, such as a closing statement or other third-party record

Our guide on what evidence to bring goes deeper on each item. Our walkthrough on finding comps for a tax protest covers the search.

Where a consultant earns the fee

Pulling comps sounds easy until you do it. You need sales in the right window, clean adjustments, proof for each sale, and a packet that fits a 15-minute hearing. Then you do it again next year.

TaxDrop’s process starts with AI-driven market data analysis and licensed consultant review on every case. We prepare the protest documents and track your deadlines. Our dashboard shows progress and savings, so you don’t chase paperwork.

There are two ways to work with us:

  • Full-service protests. We file, negotiate, attend hearings and refile each year. You pay a percentage of the tax savings, and only if we reduce your bill. That’s our no savings, no fee guarantee. Residential Property Tax Protests covers homes. We also handle commercial and agricultural property.
  • TaxDrop One. A self-service evidence package built by licensed consultants for $129 per year per property.

Landlords and investors with several properties get the biggest relief from this. Each property needs its own comps, and each has its own deadline.

Taxdrop

If you’d rather hand the comp work to licensed consultants, start on our Texas property tax consultant page.

Our view on comp reports

We think a comp report should be a short, tight argument, not a data dump. Our approach pairs AI-driven analysis of market data with a licensed consultant’s review on every case. The data finds candidate sales fast. The consultant decides which ones hold up under Texas Tax Code rules and which ones a review board would shoot down.

We also think owners shouldn’t pay for effort. They should pay for results. That’s why full-service protests run on a no savings, no fee basis, and why refiling happens automatically each year. Your value can climb again next January, and a protest you filed once doesn’t protect you next year.

The best comp report is the one you never have to explain at length. Small adjustments, close sales, clear proof.

the author

FAQ

How many comps do I need for a Texas protest?

There’s no magic number in the statute. Collin CAD’s grid model typically includes at least three sales. I’d bring three to five strong ones. Quality and closeness to your home matter more than count.

Can I use sales from last year?

Usually yes. Texas Tax Code §23.013 generally allows sales within 24 months of the valuation date, and 36 months for residential property in counties with more than 150,000 people. Sales closest to January 1 carry the most weight. Adjust older sales for market changes.

Where do I get my district’s comp report?

Ask your appraisal district for the sales it used on your property. You can make a written request before your hearing, and many districts post records online. Our protest walkthrough shows where this fits in the process.

Does a comp report prove my home’s exact value?

No. It supports a range and a median. Your goal is to show that the district’s number sits above what similar homes sold for after fair adjustments.

Sources

Paying Too Much in Property Taxes?

Let our licensed property tax experts assess your tax bill for potential savings. 92% of Texas protests we closed in 2026 got a reduction. It takes less than 3 minutes to enroll.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

⏰

Don't Miss Your Filing Deadline

🏠

For Homeowners & Landlords

💵

Pay Only $129 A Year
No Savings No Fee

FAQs

Ryder Meehan
Posted by:

Ryder Meehan

Ryder Meehan is the Co-Founder of TaxDrop and a Licensed Property Tax Protest Consultant